I just finished up a very large update to PuzzleTiles, and wanted to share a few development metrics.
The previous shipping version comprised 6,181 lines of Objective-C code in 27 files (228 lines per file), plus 559 lines in 26 header files (21 lines per file). This is actual LOC (as measured by cloc), not including comments or blank lines.
The new update comprises 7,394 lines of code: 6,417 lines of Objective-C code in 24 files (267 lines per file), plus 388 lines in 22 header files (17 lines per file), and finally, 589 lines of Swift code in 15 files (39 lines per file)
|PuzzleTiles 1.2.4||27 files, 6,181 lines||26 files, 559 lines||N/A||53 files, 6,740 lines|
|PuzzleTiles 2.0||24 files, 6,417 lines||22 files, 388 lines||15 files, 589 lines||61 files, 7,394 lines|
The largest file was (and is)
PuzzleViewController.m, the file that holds the main view controller in the app, at 962 lines of code. Not too bad, I think.
From start to finish, the update took me around 258 hours. This includes everything related to the app: research, design, development, testing, artwork, screenshots and videos for iTunes Connect, etc.. Had I done this full time (which I did not), it would have taken just over 6 weeks. That's actually kind of a long time; more time than I usually spend on an app update. To be fair, though, this was a huge update.
When I took my car to the dealer for its 100,000 mile service, the dealer told me it would cost nearly $1,000. I asked what they could possibly be doing to make it cost that much. He said they intended to basically lift up the radiator cap, and pull a new car underneath it. So it was with this app update.
I overhauled the entire UI – previously it was still iOS6-vintage. I converted everything to use Storyboards and Autolayout, adding support for all the bigger phones. I added 3x graphics for iPhone 6 Plus. I added a new tile set, and updated all the others to look better (and have 3x). I added in-app purchase, and iCloud syncing (both things with which I previously had no experience). I removed every deprecated call, and added some new APIs introduced in iOS7 and iOS8 where it made sense to do so. I rewrote a few problem areas entirely (such as my GameKit code), and made some nice enhancements to other areas (the control scheme, and sound playing, among others).
PuzzleTiles was my first iOS app, originally released in 2010, and last updated in 2012. The guy that wrote it had much less expertise than I currently possess. It was very fun to get in there and redo things with the benefit of the knowledge I've gained in the years since.
I'm reasonably sure this level of effort won't turn out to have made sense, financially. In that regard, I'd likely have done better to spend that time on other apps that actually do make money. But money wasn't the point here. I wanted PuzzleTiles to once again be an app I could be proud of. In that regard, it's already a success.
Of course, it won't hurt if you download it, and buy the in-app-purchase. :)